Science and Teaching for Field Instructors

Encouraging Student Discussion and Productive Talk

Providing opportunities for students to engage in meaning-making discussions that build on prior knowledge and promote divergent thinking, is key to helping them develop deep understandings about the natural world. Actively engaging students in conversations about their ideas builds their capacity to reason scientifically and validates their contribution to group knowledge. For the instructor, facilitating productive talk about interesting organisms and intriguing phenomena can provide a window into student thinking, as well as stimulating their curiosity about student ideas and sharing a fascination with world around us. These resources provide ideas, planning tools and teaching routines to help instructors developing the skills required to lead productive, meaning-making discussions.

View and Download Materials:

A list of suggestions and important considerations for leading discussions.

Discussion Leading Tips for the Instructor
Discussion Leading Tips for the Instructor

A short list of “best friend forever” questions that can be used in many situations to facilitate exploration, observation and discussion.

BFF Questions
BFF Questions

Short descriptions of various routines to encourage student-to-student conversations.

Discussion Routines
Discussion Routines

A flexible tool for structuring open-ended discussions.

Discussion Map
Discussion Map

A list of suggested prompts for building student skills in participating in meaning-making discussions about the natural world.

Instructor Support for Leading Meaning-Making Discussions
Instructor Support for Leading Meaning-Making Discussions

A list of suggested prompts for leading focused exploration activities and engaging students in discussion about their explorations of the natural world.

Instructor Support for Guiding Explorations
Instructor Support for Guiding Explorations